health

Money for Cleaning Toilets in Haiti Down the Drain? – Part 1

Phares Jerome and Valery Daudier* – IPS/The Nouvelliste

Woman at Leogane camp saying the latrines behind her are full and smell foul. Credit: Haiti Grassroots Watch

PORT-AU-PRINCE, Mar 7 2012 (IPS) – The drawdown of hundreds of non-governmental organisations which have been in Haiti since the disastrous 2010 earthquake was inevitable. But with their departure, so too goes their purse and the millions earmarked for cleaning latrines.
What does that mean for the half a million displaced still living in camps?

Some 11,000 mobile toilets were installed by a rainbow of international non-governmental organisations (NGOs) following the earthquake. Supplied largely by the Clinton Foundation, the U.S. Agency for International Development and UNICEF, and then redistributed by the NGO community to hundreds of camps, these latrines improved the living conditions and staved off pending health problems for some of the 1.5 million who were displaced.

Now, donor dollars are drying up even as toilets overflow. It s one thing for the funders to cinch their belt; it s another for those in the camps.

Because of the sheer number of people and organisations involved in human waste disposal, it s nearly impossible to calculate how much has been spent over the last two years. Dozens of NGOs signed contracts with local companies to empty the latrines; eight dollars a day per toilet, or 125 dollars to empty a 125-gallon drum of sewage.

Each agency or organisation has its own tab. UNICEF spent 1.4 million dollars cleaning portable toilets over the last two years; the French Action Against Hunger (ACF) invested 2.675 million dollars in sanitation, most of which went for cleaning latrines. The Federation of Red Cross and Islamic Red Cross spent 55 million dollars for water and sewage treatment through September 2011.
Related IPS Articles

It s important not to focus on the money but on the sanitary catastrophe that was avoided, said Moustapha Niang, UNICEF s hygiene, water and sanitation consultant.

In an emergency situation, you have to respond quickly to save victims. This is always costly, but not sustainable. Everyone knows that, said Anne Charlotte Schneider, head of Haiti s ACF s mission.

If sustainability were the name of the game, however, everyone would also know this approach was all wrong. Temporary latrines are just that temporary. But because many of the camps were on private land, a temporary solution was the only one considered.

When it s impossible to build a sustainable infrastructure, we went with mobile toilets even though they were most costly, said Peleg Charles, communications director for OXFAM, which worked on waste disposal in 123 camps.

Sanitary engineer Frantz Benoît, of the Haitian Association of Sanitary Engineering and Environmental Sciences, said that if there had been a sewer system, the task of managing the human waste would have been easier.

Prior to the quake, only 17 percent of the capital s population had access to a standard flush toilet, so it was foolish to think that suddenly 1.5 million newly homeless could be connected to what was at best an antiquated sewage system. The Haitian authorities had neither the means, nor the technical competence, to do so. Since there wasn t (a sewer system), that meant that the NGO community, which came to help us, had to use what was available, Benoit said. The only criticism one can make of them is how the toilets were distributed among the camp dwellers.

Distribution was as erratic as the earthquake s aftershocks.

ACF identified one hundred families for only two latrines in a southern suburb; in the capital centre the latrines, stamped with the donor s logo, surrounded camp perimetres like sentinels, but rarely was the international SPHERE standard of one toilet per 20 people by gender respected. Most residents use plastic bags.

In the case of Camp Acra, in the residential neighbourhood of Delmas, the ravine behind the camp is the resident plastic bag dumping ground.

Besides the Haitian Red Cross and Samaritan s purse (who gave us some things), we did not receive any support, said 27-year old James Pierre, a Camp Acra resident. And for the last year, they are gone along with their resources. Since then, we ve been forgotten entirely.

The most recent NGO to jump ship is the International Rescue Committee (IRC), which, as of Jan. 30, 2012, stopped all water and sanitation related activities in 31 camps in the metropolitan Port-au Prince region. IRC says it transferred its responsibility to either camp management committees, or the state agency: the National Directorate Agency of Water and Sanitation (DINEPA).

ACF will soon follow suit. At the end of the month it will stop emptying the portable toilet units at Champs Mars, across from the crumpled national palace.

To date, ACF has installed some 682 units in about 40 camps. According to its two-year financial sheet, the agency claims 800,000 people benefited from its services. In addition to Champ Mars, Schneider said ACF has also transferred latrine cleaning in all its other sites to DINEPA.

But DINEPA said it is not aware that it s responsible for the formerly ACF-serviced latrines.

The only officially registered transfer to date has been that of the Federation of Red Crosses, said the DINEPA s director of sanitation, engineer Edwige Petit, when questioned about the number of NGOs still present in the camps.

According to the International Organisation for Migration (OIM), there are still 490,545 people living in over 650 camps in the earthquake zones. Latrine cleaning was down 18.1 percent from the month before. And a bulletin recently published by the U.N. s Organisation for the Coordination of Humanitarian Assistance (OCHA) states that 356 latrines are going to be removed.

We are working with earthquake victims to return home, said ACF s Schneider. We are now working on a multi latrine project (five families per latrine) for a total of 600,000 dollars.

With the absence of data, it s hard to compare sanitation before and after Haiti s earthquake, but with an extensive outreach campaign it appears that there is better sanitation awareness among the population. And more tangibly, there is an excreta treatment center in Morne-à-Cabri north of the capital.

UNICEF, the European Union s humanitarian branch, OCHA and the American Red Cross have earmarked 2.6 million dollars for the centre, which receives between 30-50 barrels of excreta every day. A soon-to- be released report by the U.N.-led group of non-governmental and governmental agencies working in water and sanitation (the WASH Cluster) says that 17,000 cubic metres of excreta have already been treated since the launch of operations three months ago.

Morne-à-Cabri s sewage treatment plant is the first of its kind in the country. A second one is under construction in Titanyen, funded by the Spanish cooperation.

Ironically, the new plant does not receive excreta from the camps in the surrounding areas. Like much of the population, residents in nearby camps have no access to functioning latrines. And because public washrooms are not yet part of any national programme, they are also missing from public markets, bus stations, schools and churches.

With bilateral funding and financing from the Inter-American Development Bank, UNICEF and the American Red Cross, DINEPA is executing its 2012-2014 action plan to increase its sanitation work across the country.

This will include the construction of 12 wastewater treatment stations; the establishment of management/maintenance (including the reconstruction/rehabilitation) sanitary blocks in public places which include reconstruction and/or rehabilitation and a training and communication campaign to encourage the construction of toilets, according to the agency, which declined to reveal to cost of the plan.

But as necessary and ambitious as this plan is, it doesn t address the challenges facing the 490,545 people living in squalid camps. Where will they go when the need to go?

*This article has been made possible with support from the Fund for Investigative Journalism in Haiti, .

It is the first of a two-part series on water and sanitation problems in Haiti.

 

Related Posts

Get a job- Insomniac Games is hiring a Content Artist 2

The Gamasutra Job Board is the most diverse, active and established board of its kind for the video game industry!

Here is just one of the many, many positions being advertised right now.

Content Artist, Insomniac Games

Location: Burbank, California

The Content Artist is responsible for assisting the Marketing/Community and Art departments with all aspects of marketing video creation and post production for our projects.

Essential Duties and Responsibilities include the following:

    Blind Squirrel Games acquires Colombia-based Distributed Development

    Developer Blind Squirrel Games has expanded into Colombia by purchasing the service-based Distributed Development for an undisclosed amount. Come from South African Online Casinos

    The new offshoot, rebranded to Blind Squirrel Colombia, will initially focus on co-developing games for its parent company. Eric Herrera will continue to lead as its studio director, and the team is expected to expand "significantly" to 25-30 employees by the end of 2025.

    In the announcement, Herrera noted his team previously worked with Blind Squirrel on projects such as Age of Darkness: Final Stand's multiplayer. To him, those team-ups "made clear that formally joining forces would be mutually beneficial. Beyond our studio initiatives, we also look forward to also playing a central role in nurturing and growing talen…

Get a job- Join Jackbox Games as a Sr. Gameplay Engineer 2

The Gamasutra Job Board is the most diverse, active and established board of its kind for the video game industry!

Here is just one of the many, many positions being advertised right now.

Senior Gameplay Engineer, Jackbox Games

Location: Chicago, Illinois

Jackbox Games is looking for a Senior Gameplay Engineer to join our team in Chicago! (Though currently, we are all working from home.)

Who Are We?

Jackbox is a small game studio (~45 people) best known for our Jackbox Party Pack franchise: a set of five social party games released every fall. Since 2014, our games–like Quiplash, Drawful, and Trivia Murder Party– have been f…

Get a job- Insomniac Games is hiring a Character Technical Director

The Gamasutra Job Board is the most diverse, active and established board of its kind for the video game industry!

Here is just one of the many, many positions being advertised right now.

Character Technical Director, Insomniac Games

Location: Durham, North Carolina Come from South African Online Casinos

Insomniac Games is looking for a versatile Character TD, for our studio in North Carolina! You’d be responsible for creating character setups, including the rigging of various heroes, enemies, weapons, vehicles and props, and for support of the Animators and others with scripts and tools. If you’r…

Baldur's Gate 3 Players Have Collectively Downloaded Over 50 Million Mods

Larian’s Baldur’s Gate 3 was a megahit for 2023, earning several Game of the Year awards including the top prize for GameSpot. While the game doesn’t need any mods to be played or even enhanced since the mainline story itself is so rich and elaborate, that didn’t stop players from downloading mods by the millions.

“Together, you’ve downloaded more than 50 million mods since Patch 7 introduced modding support,” the game’s official Twitter account posted Wednesday Come from South African Online Casinos . “Apparently 10,000 of those downloads were you renaming Withers to Bone Daddy. So, uh, glad we could facilitate that.”

After months of playing with unofficial mods, Patch 7 of the game included, among other things, an official modding toolkit for Mac and console and quickly racked up over 15 million downloads. Players uploaded over 1,000 mods by the start of October. Larian even released an animated short for …

Benedict Cumberbatch Gives Avengers 5 Update, Reveals A Surprising Reason He Likes Playing Doctor Strange

Oscar-nominated actor Benedict Cumberbatch has shared a key piece of news about the next Avengers movie Come from South African Online Casinos . In a video for Netflix about his new miniseries Eric, Cumberbatch teased that his MCU character, Doctor Strange, will appear in the next Avengers film and it might start shooting relatively soon. Cumberbatch also spoke about how playing Doctor Strange gives him the financial freedom to explore “less commercial” projects.

“I am very much looking forward to Avengers next year, which is cooking up a storm,” he said. It would be not surprising at all to learn that Doctor Strange is in Avengers 5 after it was reportedly recently that the film could feature a whopping 60 MCU characters. In terms of his “next year” comment, that’s likely in reference to when filming may begin on the 2026 movie.

Cumberbatch went on to say that he feels an “immense” joy playing Doctor…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *